A constable’s brave reply to Prime Minister Modi!

On October 2, 2014, during the launch of the Swachh Bharat campaign, Prime Minister Narendra Modi picked up a broom to sweep the parking area of Mandir Marg Police Station in New Delhi. He then asked the police personnel present why they did not keep their workplace clean.

While all the other police personnel responded with the usual embarrassed silence, one constable told Modi the police station was not clean because “a majority of them (policemen) remained occupied with his security route and they just didn’t have the time for anything else”.

The constable’s honest, and brave, reply has prompted the PMO (Prime Minister’s Office) to re-evaluate the deployment of nearly 500 security personnel during Mr. Modi’s movement in the Capital. This India Today report quotes a senior police official: “On October 3, a new set of guidelines for the security arrangements came from the PMO which clearly asked the Delhi Police to deploy only the required number of personnel for the prime minister’s security instead of turning the city into a fortress.”

The constable deserves praise for having had the courage to speak up to the Prime Minister! Police personnel are usually silent in the presence of ministers, legislators and politicians since speaking up may invite overt or covert punishment.

Equally importantly, it must be appreciated that Mr. Modi took the constable’s feedback in the proper spirit!! Politicians normally do not act on inconvenient feedback from policemen and government employees, but ‘reward’ the giver of such blunt feedback with some form of punishment.

Will we see more persons following the constable’s example and more politicians following Mr. Modi’s example?

I believe that this incident will inspire more persons to give honest feedback to Mr. Modi. If Mr. Modi responds to all such feedback in the proper spirit, we will see more politicians following his example. Change will not take place overnight, but it will take place.

What do you think?

16 thoughts on “A constable’s brave reply to Prime Minister Modi!

  1. Didn’t know about this, but I am happy to have read about it here. Thanks Pro for highlighting this, it may seem like a small story but is really big in its potential impact.

  2. Mr Modi is known to be a vindictive man. I pity the constable whose future may not be as bright as it would have been had he said, “PM sir, you have inspired us now and in future it will all be very clean here.”

  3. Change I would say is happening. May be at a smaller pace. But it definitely is happening. For good. I’m hoping for some transformation for the nation and its people. To me Modiji’s understanding here is much more appreciable than the constable’s honest feedback. Most politicians would have always issued suspension orders or transfer orders.

  4. Very rarely we see people like the constable who had the guts to speak to the Prime Minister of India, and the Prime Minister of India taking action on a constable’s view. Thanks for sharing. I think I came across this news in a fleeting glance but read it properly only now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s