Win – Win (An unbelievable, but true story!)

The union leader promised the workers that he would ensure that they were given a 20% salary increase during the Annual Wage Agreement later that month. “If the management does not agree, we will go on strike,” he declared. The workers cheered!

3 days later, he sent the company’s Chairman a letter demanding 20% salary increase for all employees as part of the Annual Wage Agreement.

2 hours after receiving the letter, the Chairman telephoned the union leader and invited him for a meeting the next afternoon to discuss the Annual Wage Agreement. “I’ll certainly attend the meeting, but there’s nothing to discuss. We will not accept anything less than 20%,” the union leader said.

The next afternoon, the Chairman asked the union leader, “You said you’ll not accept anything less than 20%, but can I offer 35%?” The union leader was too stunned to reply!

The Chairman continued, “Our workers can get 35% higher salary, but only if they help the company generate the additional money to pay them that 35%. I’m offering 10% salary increase, 10% Attendance Incentive, 10% Productivity Incentive, plus a 5% Turnover Incentive. Of course, they will continue to get 8.33% Bonus, Leave Encashment and other existing benefits. Please discuss my offer with the workers and let me know the response. All details are here in this file.” The union leader took the file and left the Chairman’s office.

Two days later, the union leader told the workers that this was the first time in the last 22 years that any management had offered more than the union had demanded. He explained the details of the Chairman’s offer and explained why he was convinced that it was a genuine offer with no hidden surprises. The workers agreed that the union should accept the Chairman’s offer.

The Annual Wage Agreement was signed by the Chairman and the union leader two days later.

The company’s turnover increased by 50% the next year without any increase in the number of workers, all due to near-zero absenteeism and a substantial increase in efficiency and productivity. As agreed, the workers also earned 35% higher salary than the previous year.


11 thoughts on “Win – Win (An unbelievable, but true story!)

  1. I very well know of trade unionism while at Voltas, where they opposed computerization and later at Delhi as a CFO when a lockout had to be declared.
    There is certainly much that the company managements and the union leaders can do, if only they believe in a common endeavour and not go into a confrontation course. .

  2. This comes as a surprise, but since you’ve shared this, we know it is a true story. Some people have an uncanny ability to motivate us. Here the Management knew how to create the win-win situation ! Wonderful , Pro 🙂

  3. Management rocked…….Union leader shocked.
    The Unions job is to protect the interests of the workers by negotiating & bargaining not by going on strikes. Actually if you have good management like the one you describe then you don’t even need a union.

  4. I like to question the need for a union. Ideally speaking, if the management and supervisors do what is needed, then a union is not needed.

    The case you’ve shared is a rather unique case.. It is very rare to see the management to be so forthright about their business case, and at the same time paying back the operators who work on line.

  5. Wow! That’s an awesome story and truly a win-win situation. People with vision and goals make them successful in every sphere of life!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s